Showing posts with label lawsuits. Show all posts
Showing posts with label lawsuits. Show all posts

Friday, January 4, 2008

Antitrust lawsuit against Apple?

Well, when one company occupies such a large percentage of the online audio/video market and hardware market, it's bound to come up eventually...

Information Week is reporting on Plaintiff Stacie Somers who filed suit on Dec 31 (Happy New Year?), claiming Apple maintains an illegal monopoly on the digital music market.

Apparently the major point of contention is Apple's unwillingness to support protected media from sources other than iTunes.
The complaint takes issue with Apple's refusal to support the Windows Media Audio format. "Apple's iPod is alone among mass-market Digital Music Players in not supporting the WMA format," it states, noting that America Online, Wal-Mart, Napster, MusicMatch, Best Buy, Yahoo Music, FYE Download Zone, and Virgin Digital all support protected WMA files.
The suit goes on to claim that even though the iPod is physically capable of playing protected media from sources other than iTunes, this feature is deliberately crippled in the player's software.

What I'm unclear on, and what the article doesn't really elaborate on, is the injury to the consumer.
As for the injury to consumers, the complaint says that Apple's pricing is "monopolistic, excessive, and arbitrary," citing how a wholesale $5.52 price difference between 1-Gbyte ($4.15) and 4-Gbyte ($9.67) NAND flash memory modules results in a $100 retail price difference between 1-Gbyte iPod Nano and a 4-Gbyte Nano.
If the complaint is with the software, I don't understand what the price inflation of the hardware has to do with that, other than the obvious claim of collusion with memory makers.
Another interesting point (briefly touched on) is the recent popularity of DRM free music (Sony recently caving for example), and it's unclear what impact that might have on the suit.

Apple of course has no comment.

Read the whole article here @ Information Week

Saturday, August 18, 2007

Cingular (AT&T) Waiver Ruled "Unconscionable" By Circuit Court


"Like many companies, Cingular has a little thing in their contracts saying that if you use their service, you void your right to a class action lawsuit and instead have to go through "mandatory binding arbitration," which is basically an extra-judicial corporate court exempt from many of the basic laws and procedures and rights of real court."


This is a step in the right direction for those of us wanting a little more control over what services we use. I for one can't wait until companies like at&t, Verizon, and Sprint are finally sued over not allowing us to unlock our phones.

read more | digg story

Wednesday, August 1, 2007

Eminem Sues Apple for Music Rights

"Eight Mile Style and Martin Affiliated, Eminem’s music publisher and copyright manager, has filed a multimillion-dollar lawsuit against Apple, alleging that the company violated copyrights by allowing downloads of Eminem’s songs onto iPods."

read more | digg story

Tuesday, July 31, 2007

RIAA backtracks after embarrassing P2P defendant

When the RIAA filed a file-sharing lawsuit against a sergeant in the US Army earlier this year, it included thousands of files containing pornography that had nothing to do with the case. The Sgt. decided to fight back, by filing a counterclaim accusing the RIAA of violating his privacy.

read more | digg story

Friday, July 20, 2007

Charting the $480 billion US spectrum giveaway

A story out of Ars Technica,
I can't say I'm surprised that our federal government would practically give away air worth billions of dollars. They've demonstrated time and again, that they have no working knowledge of, do not value, and seem to fear anything remotely "techie".
A report on spectrum lobbying from the New America Foundation argues that the FCC has given away up to $480 billion in spectrum rights since 1993. Here's how taxpayers are being cheated.

"The giveaway that Snider's talking about isn't a massive grant of free spectrum to corporate interests; instead, it's something much more subtle and far more difficult for the public to understand. To understand why Snider considers this a "giveaway," let's first look at the difference between the amount of money the government has actually received for licenses since 1993 and the amount of money that such licenses are worth."

read more | digg story

Here's hoping a good chunk of air goes to Google in 2009....

Tuesday, July 17, 2007

RIAA's final tab for Capitol vs. Foster: $68,685.23

DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE!!!
The book is closed on one of the most closely-followed file-sharing cases, as a judge tallies up the ledger for Debbie Foster's legal bills. $68,685.23 was awarded in HER favor.

My Favorite part:
"This past February, Judge West awarded Foster attorneys' fees, citing the RIAA's insistence on pressing the secondary infringement case and saying that he could find no case "holding the mere owner of an Internet account contributorily or vicariously liable for the infringing activities of third persons."
He also rejected the RIAA's argument that Foster was not entitled to fees incurred after "some point when she allegedly 'could have avoided [fees] altogether but chose not to do so,'" reiterating that she was fully entitled to fight the RIAA's charges and as a result, eligible for an award of attorneys' fees."
SWEET!

read more | digg story

Monday, July 9, 2007

Music Industry Shaking Down Coffee Shops

Gotta love it.
The record companies are hemorrhaging, and they still can't figure out any other way to make money, other than suing their fans. It's really sad, but is bloody fascinating to watch.

This is my favorite part:
"Andrus said a friend of his who owned a restaurant that did not feature music was contacted by a company looking to charge him because it owned the rights to a Hank Williams Jr. song, "Are You Ready for Some Football?" The song preceded every "Monday Night Football" telecast, which the restaurant carried on its televisions."

read more | digg story

Monday, June 25, 2007

Exonerated defendant sues RIAA for malicious prosecution

Disabled single mother takes the fight back to the RIAA!

From Arstechnica:

"We explored the possibility of charging the RIAA with malicious prosecution last month. Attorney Rich Vasquez of Morgan Miller Blair told Ars Technica that he believed the RIAA could be vulnerable to such charges, but it would be an uphill battle to make them stick. Still, the complaint paints a very unflattering picture of the RIAA and its agents engaging in activity that was in many cases questionable and unethical at best.The history of file-sharing litigation shows that Atlantic v. Andersen was not an isolated case of mistaken identity, and should Andersen get a favorable result here, other former defendants may follow her lead.

That could lead to a potentially very costly class-action suit against the RIAA. "You'd have to have a lot of winners," said Vasquez. "If you have enough people bringing charges of malicious prosecution, you could then show a pattern of practices on the part of the RIAA."The RIAA told Ars that it would have no comment on Andersen's lawsuit.
"



read more | digg story

Thursday, June 21, 2007

Kinda Funny, RIAA should Sue Bush's Daughters for $1,800,000 in Damages

From Digg: "Mitchell Silverman, an attorney in Florida, noticed in a recent news-story that GW Bush's twin daughters presented him with a mix CD of exercise music for Father's Day. Since the record industry maintains that making and distributing mix CDs is a copyright infringement, Silverman sent their legal offices a letter on letterhead asking them to sue."

Check out the The Scrivener story, the comments are "teh hysterical".
I love the one guy that always takes things like this literally.
Anonymous:
"I'm willing to bet that every single one of you have made or received a mix tape or CD at some point in your life -- do you feel like you owe someone $1.8 mil?"

Heh-heh...love that guy.

He posts on EVERY blog...


someaudioguy some audio guy record labels piracy p2p george w bush illegal downloading ipod

read more | digg story

Judge deals blow to RIAA, says students can respond to John Doe lawsuit, GO ALBUQUERQUE!!!

Can't help it. Every now and then my home town does right...

"The RIAA will not be able to use a John Doe lawsuit to obtain the identities of 16 people accused of using the University of New Mexico's network for copyright infringement—at least not until the targets are notified of the legal action."



read more | digg story

Monday, March 19, 2007

WHOA! RIAA OVERLOAD!

Holy CRAP! What's going on?
NYTimes, Digg, Gizmodo, Consumerist, Blogs, University News sites, They're all going crazy with stories on the RIAA, on a variety of sources, and all (oddly) seem universally against the RIAA.

So weird...

For those of you to lazy to source your own news on the future of how you listen, control, use, and own your media, here's today's rundown.

I don't like Consumerist. I don't at all. I think they get too antagonistic when it comes to apathetic employees working McJobs, instead of fighting where the problems actually come from, but one thing they are really good at is tracking down corporate contact info. Ever want to know who actually heads up the RIAA, and how to contact said individuals. Click on the link below.
Faces of the RIAA @ Consumerist


David Byrne (of the talking heads) was at SXSW, and "making sense" according to the NYTimes. Uhh neat ... I guess ... But seriously, I totally disagree with some of his assessments on artists needing labels (I think they'll be totally broken and vestigial in my lifetime at least), but on the whole it's a pretty good read.
Rocker David Byrne Making Sense at SXSW Fest

This one I don't even have a write up for. Here the RIAA just tries to explain why attacking college students with extortion tactics is good for business, and why they are upset that colleges aren't selling their (customers) students out. A fascinating look at ... well ... the main enemy to media property rights and fair use.
From insidehighered.com:
Explaining the Crackdown on Student Downloading

Ok, not directly about the RIAA, but a great blog posting on an actual Pirate (sure capital 'P'). According to the RIAA if you download music from teh intarwebs then you are a "pirate". However, I prefer a more traditional definition of pirate, where one tries to profit from their plundering, and wouldn't you know it, p2p/file sharing is really starting to hurt the people who sell bootlegs. Score a victory point for p2p!
From Torrentfreak:
P2P File-Sharing Ruins Physical Piracy Business


Man that was a lot! And really that's just the tip of the iceberg. There just seems to be a lot discontent with the media market right now. I wonder when people will start doing something about it...
someaudioguy some audio guy music voice over albums copyright riaa piracy p2p record labels

Saturday, March 17, 2007

Quick follow up to Youtube vs Viacom

Well Techdirt is saying that since Viacom can sue Google for what people put up on Youtube, that content providers should be able to sue Viacom for illegally removing content that doesn't infringe on Viacom copyright.

This is kinda interesting again...

Friday, March 16, 2007

Viacom vs Youtube, and why I don't care that much...

Tim Goodman at the San Francisco Chronicle has written a great article, which I largely agree with, about why this lawsuit kinda doesn't matter.

He makes some excellent points regarding the fact that for us "little people" who provide content for these sites, we'll not see any compensation for our work. Google will find a way to make money off of YouTube, and Viacom will find a way to force Google to pay them for the privilege of showing clips of their shows.
That last point burns me up, as fans of these shows are pretty much using YouTube to freely ADVERTISE this media. Without the online fan community, I really don't believe that shows like 30 Rock and My Name is Earl (great though they may be) would have nearly the same viewership they do now.
It reminds me of the early days of Napster, where people were swapping songs like crazy, and album sales were rising. When Lars started suing people is around the same time as people stopped buying their music...

Wednesday, March 14, 2007

Get Him RIAA! GET HIM!

For those of you keeping track of the HILARITY and illegal-ness of recent RIAA lawsuits, this is old news. For those of you who haven't been watching as our civil liberties are being pissed away, read on!

Apparently the RIAA is tired of trying to extort money out of able-bodied young college students (that's SO Napster). Now they're going after partially paralyzed stroke victims... specifically one accused of file sharing in Michigan... though he was living in Florida at the time of his alleged "crimes".

[ahem]

Yup.
It's a great read.
Check it out here @ Recording Industry Vs The People:

RIAA Sues Stroke Victim in Michigan