Showing posts with label MPAA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label MPAA. Show all posts

Friday, September 12, 2008

Re-Examining a Tax on File Sharing

I've been thinking about this quite a bit lately.

I think we can all agree that the current media marketplace is broken.
The music and movie industries refuse to deliver on a system consumers want, namely something transparent and easy to use. When we get close, with services like Netflix, iTunes, or Amazon, there are either too many odd restrictions on how we can use our purchase, or there's a severely limited catalog of content.
Consumers have since resorted to file sharing, which offers a nearly unlimited catalog, no restrictions on use, is fairly easy to use, and depending on file, is as fast or faster than "legit" purchasing. Through the inactivity of the media industry, consumers have created the market they want to use. This is how people want to do business.

So why not monetize it?

It's become apparent, that left to their own devices, Industry solutions are insufficient, sometimes so broken the only reason for releasing them seems to be confusing the customer, scaring them away from digital distribution. The thinking being, if it's "too hard" to buy online, then we'll just go back to buying the discs.

If The Industry wont do it, why not internet service providers?

I know they're trying to deliver their own video on demand services, and have recently been instituting data caps on broadband subscribers, but they could stand to make a lot more money this route. The idea has been considered before, and a similar plan might go into effect in the UK, but the efforts all seem to stop at the idea of decriminalization. All of these ideas seem to involve a minimal annual fee ($20-$60) to "look the other way" for those that file share. Basically it would turn the whole internet into one giant Netflix. Unfortunately it seems that EVERYONE would be subject to this tax, not just those that engage in file sharing.

Of COURSE people wont like that. Why should we all pay for the actions of some. It would be similar to the levy imposed on blank CD's in Canada. It did decriminalize trading music via burned discs, but EVERYONE had to pay for it.

If we've learned anything from marketplace economics, we should be touting this as a feature (not shaming it), and then charging monthly for it. Let's borrow Netflix. If ISP's offered an optional "File Sharing" plan that you could choose to sign up for, and charged a fair rate for it, it would generate substantial revenue, and wouldn't be a burden on those not using the service.

Let's fudge some numbers.
Roughly estimating 110 million households in the USA, approximately 55% of households have high speed internet, or about 60.5 million households.
Let's set the "Digital Media Downloading" plan at an additional $25 a month.
I'd be willing to bet that by the end of the first year about 30% of broadband subscribers would sign up.

This would generate over $450 million a MONTH.

Almost half a billion dollars a month, and other than a hit to bandwidth, consumers would take care of everything. With file sharing you don't have to store a product on your own servers, the consumers do it. You don't have to advertise file sharing, the consumers do it for you. You don't have to rip music or movies, consumers do it for you. You don't have to troubleshoot or provide tech support, consumers do it for you.

In what other industry could you generate $5 BILLION annually for letting your customers do all the work?

Sunday, September 2, 2007

Piracy hurts Box Office? ... Even During Record Setting Summer?

There is a fantastic article up over at Ars Technica that pretty much sums up how I've felt about the MPAA/RIAA's war on "Piracy".


Despite concerns about the extent of piracy, the movie business has
pulled in record revenues this summer, earning more than $4 billion in
box revenues in the US alone.

Media by Numbers, which tracks such things, estimates that the industry will rake in $4.15 billion
(PDF) by the end of Labor Day. That's despite record-high average
ticket prices of $6.85, up $0.30 from a year ago. That's even despite
claims that piracy is on the rise, and it's harming the industry.

It couldn't be that the movies were just a lot better this year?

It goes on to talk about the lack of forward thinking for technologies. Pretty much the same trap that the Music industry fell into around Napster. If anyone had embraced mp3 back then , I don't think music would be as de-valued as it is today (at least in album form).

Watching the Movie industry scramble to come up with newer and more confusing copy protections (which are usually cracked within weeks
09-F9-11-02-9D-74-E3-5B-D8-41-56-C5-63-56-88-C0), is pretty self destructive. These measures only serve to stop average consumers from using the content in a legitimate manner. Trust me, anyone who really wants to get around these copy protection schemes will be able to, but those just looking for the convenience of popping in a cassette tape will be sorely disappointed. Something tells me it'll most likely get worse before it gets better.

It's all wrapped up in this "consumers are pirates" mentality (read here for my take on "piracy"). Just because suits can't understand what this technology means, it perpetuates this idea of everyone trying to steal from them. If they would just consider this from a consumers point of view, for just a second, they could stand to make SO much more money. I'll give you two options:

1. Drive to store. Browse limited selection. Pick best of what they have. Wait in line at cash register. Pay, and then be asked for your receipt as you leave by big burly rent-a-cop that saw you pay. Drive home. Spend about 5 minutes or so dealing with plastic wrap, stickers, tabs. Pop DVD in player. Sit through trailers. Sit through commercials. Sit through FBI Warning. Sit through commercial telling you Piracy is wrong. Get to Disc Menu. Play movie.

2. Browse for exactly the movie you want online. Wait about 3-4 hours for it to download (over broadband of course). Burn it to disc. Pop it in DVD player. DVD menu pops up. Watch Movie.

Now, obviously today option 1 is legit Best Buy style, and option 2 is file-sharing, but what if some forward thinking exec saw option 2 and said "Wow, the consumers have already created a business model for us. All we have to do is slap a price tag on it".

Let's say option one is $14.99, and option 2 were $9.99 (no packaging, no shipping, no stocking, no paying snotty employees - just pure profit after data costs) which one would you rather patron?

Check out the Ars Technica article it is a great summary of whats going on, and where we could be.


Monday, August 20, 2007

TRUE Piracy

I get a little frustrated when I hear RIAA and MPAA and lawyers talking about "piracy".

They seem to equate filesharing with being a pirate.

I disagree with this.

I believe the filesharing of copyrighted material is "stealing".

I believe for a person to commit an act of piracy, there must be an intent to profit off of someone else's copyrighted material.


This guy is a Pirate:



read more | digg story

Tuesday, June 26, 2007

How to clean DVD and CD discs

These guides show up every so often, but it's good info to know. Especially if the RIAA/MPAA convince (bribe) our government to make duplication illegal. Better take good care of that media, so click the link at the bottom to read all about it.

read more | digg story
someaudioguy some audio guy recording cd dvd disc voice over voice acting demo production how to
***Almost forgot, for scratched media try toothpaste!

Monday, April 2, 2007

What Exactly ARE Your Copyright Rights?

With the RIAA and MPAA working to "teach" kids about copyright law (from their perspective of course, not an actual legal perspective), it's good to see sites like Digital Freedom pop up.

In a world where the XXAA's would prefer we not even be allowed to back up our media, or rip our own cd's for fair personal use, setting down a Consumer Bill of Rights is long over due.

First check out this write up on Ars Technica, then head over to DFU, and get the full low down.

"With the DFU initiative, Digital Freedom wants to paint a bigger picture of copyright law for students, one that is not forthcoming from the movie and music industries. "The Digital Freedom University Initiative will fight to ensure that these thousands of college-age students, who represent future artists, innovators and consumers, fully understand their rights, and have a voice in the long- term solution."
someaudioguy some audio guy voice over music production recording demo auditions

Sunday, April 1, 2007

U of Illinois Caves to RIAA

Well looks like UofI is thinking it's too expensive to continue holding the RIAA/MPAA at bay.

"As you may have read in the popular press, the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) and the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) among others are increasing their copyright enforcement activities. As part of this increased effort, the RIAA has begun to target college students specifically, which means that students who engage in unlawful peer-to-peer file sharing are more likely than ever to be identified and sued by the RIAA."

...

"The University does not condone the use of peer-to-peer software for illegal file sharing. Those who engage in it violate U.S. Copyright laws as well as the campus's own policies, including the Student Code and Policy on the Appropriate Use of the Computer Network. Additionally the University bears significant costs associated with responding to DMCA violation notices and the network capacity absorbed by file sharing reduces its availability for general research, teaching, and administrative purposes."


Fair 'nuff, I 'spose. Sharing copyrighted materials IS illegal.
Though, I find it troubling that courts are still allowing lawsuits from the XXAA's. There seems like there's so little info to go off of for a convincing lawsuit, to show without doubt that damage has been done. Going after Universities doesnt seem kosher to me either. That they can't actually find who it is that is violating the DMCA, and when they do issue a lawsuit, often it seems spurious (like this computer less family).
But then there's this...

"Further, some file sharing programs, even when used for legitimate purposes, will use your computer to transfer illegally obtained material between other users. I strongly encourage you to remove software used for file sharing as well as to immediately remove any illegally obtained material such as music or movies."

Now that's just FUD. Plain and simple. Next you'll be telling me that file sharing will cause me to have my kidneys cut out of me, and sold on the black market. I'll wake up in a bathtub full of ice in a cheap motel room in Juarez...
"DAMN YOU FILE SHARING!!!!"


I very much believe that the XXAA's think if they repeat enough legal un-truth's often enough, that it will just become true (and "the law"). While at the same time media markets just fall completely apart, and organizations that should be concerned with maintaining the careers of artists plunge into the toilet.

Sure, keep hiring lawyers.

That'll help...

Tuesday, March 20, 2007

Piracy NOT Illegal?

Man, this guy is hardcore.

I read every bit of information I could find, including case law. I studied the DMCA. Since then I have studied the NET Act. I have studied everything I could find. Guess what? I could not find a single line in any act that said that downloading anything was illegal, or even anything that could be construed to mean it.

Ok, I get that the technical terms for delivery of content might not be included in the articles of the DMCA, but somehow I'm still pretty sure that the sharing of content (regardless of method of receipt) is still against the law.

Though I totally agree with him about how annoying the "file sharing is stealing" commercials are.

Here, I've bought this DVD. I've had my bag checked as I left the store. I've removed plastic wrap. Struggled with those damned adhesive strips, and almost broken the tabs off of the case just to open the DVD. With great satisfaction I place the DVD in my player, turn on the TV, and ... have to watch ... a GAHD DAMED COMERCIAL ABOUT HOW STEALING IS WRONG?!?! THAT I CAN'T SKIP OVER!!! WHAT?!? REALLY!?!?!

So my reward for purchasing this movie is to get treated like a criminal! GEEZUS! Next time I'll just download it...




...



I mean, I love movies!

Finish this guy's article here:
Downloading Pirated Anything Is NOT Illegal @ Untwisted Vortex