Showing posts with label reader question. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reader question. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 2, 2008

Dedicated Preamp or Directly into Your Soundcard?

I've gotten this question a couple times, so I figured it was time to throw some equipment at the problem.
Should you plug your mic directly into your soundcard (or mixer), or should you invest in a dedicated preamp?

The answer is "yes".

Either.

Correct.

Let's take a listen!
For today's experiment, we're going to use my M-Audio Solaris because it's a decent budget condenser microphone, and it's become one of my favorite work horse microphones.

The two preamps we're going to compare it with are the Behringer T1953, which I've had for a while now...

...and, an ART Tube PAC, which I've only just recently acquired.

To keep everything as neutral as possible, I'm recording into my Firewire 410.


All recordings were done 6 inches from the mic's diaphragm, and have not been edited (unless noted) accept for compression to 320Kbps MP3 for streaming (initial recording were done @ 24/96).
The PAC was used low threshold with 3:1 compression.

Solaris direct to FW410 (very quiet):
Get this widget | Track details | eSnips Social DNA

Solaris direct to FW410 Normalized (loud):
Get this widget | Track details | eSnips Social DNA

Solaris with Behringer T1953 (loud):
Get this widget | Track details | eSnips Social DNA

Solaris with Art Tube PAC (loud):
Get this widget | Track details | eSnips Social DNA


OK, so what can we glean?
Well, none of these sound "bad" to me. I prefer the sound of the PAC, it's a little fuller than the direct to soundcard, but I still feel like that sounds like me, natural.
The T1953 sounds "hotter" or "louder" (odd as it doesn't have a compressor like the PAC), but it adds a slightly unnatural timbre or edge to my voice. It's a subtle texture that's not unpleasant, but I don't feel that's what I really sound like. Also the T1953 adds a bit more noise to the chain than the PAC.
The direct to soundcard is the cleanest of the group, but is also the plainest to me. It's not bad, just vanilla, and we all know that vanilla is the best "base" ice cream. I think this recording would probably be the easiest to EQ and mix in front of music on a commercial.

As with so much of what we do, if you're already working a mic you like with a good soundcard, then adding a preamp (especially ones like my budget preamps) isn't going to bring an earth shaking difference to your recordings. It can make editing easier however as it instantly brings up the level of your recordings, giving you a nice hot signal to work with, but it can also make editing harder if your preamp is noisy.

For us VO people, I can only recommend buying a dedicated Pre if you've compared a few, and you've picked one out that compliments your mic and soundcard in accentuating the qualities of your voice you MOST want people to hear.

And of course, everything in this article can be purchased through SOME AUDIO STORE, LOL!
someaudioguy some audio guy voice over recording auditions VO voice acting equipment kit gear microphone preamp soundcard digital audio interface

Saturday, March 15, 2008

AudioGuy Mail Bag - Some Audition Questions...

This question comes in from Janet, who has a few technical questions about her auditions:

I love all your Some Audio Guy postings and you've been a big help.
I've done on-camera and voice over work for many years as a radio and TV
anchor/reporter but now am after strictly voice-over work.

Here are my questions -

In my home studio, I can't hear my voice in the headphones while I'm recording
with Audacity or Adobe Soundbooth CS3 - playback is no problem.
(it was set up by a broadcast engineer friend but I never
noticed that I couldn't hear in the headphones when he was
here, or maybe I've done something wrong since.)

Also - if my intention is to supply "dry reads" from my home studio, how much
cleaning up should I do on the auditions? if I take out breaths and normalize
the volume (as you show on your video) is that a false impression of what I
intend to deliver? Isn't that more an "I can deliver edited and finished voice tracks" as voice123 says or do I misunderstand the term "dry read?"

Whew, that's a lots of questions all wrapped into one. I appreciate any help you can give me.

Thanks - Janet


Hey Janet,
About hearing yourself while recording, that can be a little tricky, It's largely going to come down to what sound card you're using to record. Most modern external soundcards should be fast enough to let you monitor. Depending on what recording software you're using, there should be a recording setting to allow hardware monitoring. Now this is where latency comes into play. Your card has to sample the audio you create (vibrations in the air), translate it into a digital signal (1' and 0's), and pass it over a USB or FW cable to your computer, WHILE re-routing it to your headphones. If you dont have a reasonably quick soundcard/computer setup, then you'll hear yourself as an echo with a split second delay.

As for this notion of "dry reads", well I just try to go for simple. Some of the casting studios use dynamic mics plugged directly into a mixer into the mic port on a computer (no soundcard at all). They do this so their recordings aren't good enough to use for an actual spot, but are good enough to hear what the actors are doing. This doesn't seem to negatively affect their business (though I can't say I love the quality of the recordings).
I say, as long as you're being honest about your talents, then do what you're comfortable doing. If you get to the end of an audition, and you have to do a ton of editing to make it sound good, then maybe it's not for you.

I tend to leave breath noise in auditions, except for deep breaths before and after copy (like my big sigh in the video). One they are perfect points to edit around, and two there's an odd psychological trick to long copy. If an audience member hears continuous monologue, but no breathing, it can cause a little distress (like when you see an action movie, and the hero dives underwater for 10 minutes, the audience will try to hold their breath along with said hero).

I think normalizing is fine, as long as it's done subtly (you want your sound balanced nothing too spikey loud or too quiet), though I would avoid heavy compression (audio not MP3 compression). You really don't want a solid WALL of sound. You never know what kind of speakers you'll be played on, so you could sound really muddy or distorted. It's like music mixing, you want to sound the same on crappy car speakers as you do on a $15K home theater. It's not glamorous, but it's a better way to represent yourself.

Thanks for the question (I'll probably steal it for the blog ;-), and thanks for reading!
-SomeAudioGuy
someaudioguy some audio guy mailbag question help how to recording music voice over voice acting auditioning acting actors animation commercial

Sunday, November 4, 2007

Audio Guy mail bag: Booth for home recording?

Just got this email in:

Hey,
Should I be worried about setting up a booth? Most of what I do is auditioning from home, but I do get the occasional gig which would be nice to do too.
-J.S.

Thanks J. I get this question quite a bit. Should you be "worried"? No. Should you be considering it? Yes. But with anything else we do, you really need to be honest with yourself over what you want versus what you need.

If you were recording promos and trailers every day, then you would be making the kind of income where devoting a whole room of your house, and getting an ISDN, and hiring a part time engineer (like ... me for example) would make sense. If most of what you're doing is auditioning though, then I don't think a booth is the way to go.

Would it help? Sure.

Enough to warrant the building cost and support? Probably not.

Most people at this stage of the game are much better served by taking a few simple (and cheap) precautions to ensure your recordings are as clean as possible.

Really, it's about knowing your equipment.
Most microphones are directional to some degree. Meaning, they should only pick up sound from a specific side or "face" of the mic. Most vocal mics are cardioid mics (cardioid ... cardiac, heart? Get it?), and they will have a subtle fan or "heart" shape recording pattern on one side of the mic. The other side of the mic will be dead.
Generally speaking, as long as the room you're in is fairly quiet (fairly closed off from the rest of the house), then you should be able to reduce reflection by treating just one or two walls or a corner of the room.

When you have flat hard walls in a room, and you're trying to record, the sound is bouncing all around. So, when you speak, the sound of your voice travels all the way across the room, bounces off a wall, travels all the way back to the wall behind you, bounces off that wall, and goes back into the mic AGAIN. Of course, that bouncing delays the sound going back into the mic, so you get a slight echo or reverberation ("reverb") effect. Now a little room tone is good. It gives the listener a sense of perspective, but hard surface reflection is often the first sign of an amateur recording (kinda like taking your headshots with a disposable camera).

So how do you fix it?

Well there are two main schools of thought on that. You can either try to block your voice from reflecting on the far wall, or you can block the reflection from the wall behind you. Ideally you would want to do both.
I find it's easier to hang a nice heavy blanket or rug, and record with your back to that. It works best if you can set it up in a corner, and make a little "blanket bowl" to catch reflected sound.
There are contraptions that can bolt on to mic stands that should absorb some of your voice's reflections, but they can be a little pricey, and I think some of them are a little too small to block ceiling and floor reflections. They also wont solve the problem of a hard surface behind you. Ideally, again, you'd want something behind you AND behind the mic, but I don't really think that's always necessary.
Keep the mic as far from your computer as you can (and try to point the "dead" end towards it), and if you have hardwood floors, it's time to throw a rug down.

Steps like these will work wonders for beginning home recording, and are easy and inexpensive to set up. As you become more successful, THEN you can look at the cost of building a room, or plunking down on a pre-fab Whisper Room type thing (the tinniest starting at almost $3000, whew!).

If you want something modular (that you can put up and take down easily) check out this PVC pipe project from PalmCityStudios.

Here's an article from a Wired blog about a professional marimba player, and what she had to go through to sound proof her NY apartment.

And lastly, heres a great Sound on Sound article about (not) setting up a booth.

Enjoy!